[1]晋 文.秦代确有算赋辨——与臧知非先生商榷[J].中国农史,2018,37(05):48-55.
　JIN Wen.Analysis of the Existence about Suanfu(Poll Tax)in the Qin Dynasty—— Discuss with Mr. Zang zhifei[J].SAMSON,2018,37(05):48-55.
点击复制

秦代确有算赋辨
——与臧知非先生商榷()
分享到：

《中国农史》[ISSN:1000-4459/CN:32-1061/S]

卷:
37
期数:
2018年05期
页码:
48-55
栏目:
出版日期:
2018-10-31

文章信息/Info

Title:
Analysis of the Existence about Suanfu(Poll Tax)in the Qin Dynasty
—— Discuss with Mr. Zang zhifei
文章编号:
1000-4459（2018）05-0048-08
作者:
晋 文
（南京师范大学 历史系，江苏 南京 210097）
Author(s):
JIN Wen
（History Department, Nanjing Normal University, Nanjing 210097）
关键词:
秦代; 算赋; 一算; 十妻不算; 里耶秦简
Keywords:
the Qin dynasty;  the Suanfu(Poll Tax);  One Suan;  Shiqibusuan;  the Bamboo and Wooden Slips excavated in Liye
分类号:
S-09；K207
文献标志码:
A
摘要:
以往学界都认为秦代确有算赋，笔者还曾提出秦代算赋仅向妇女征收的看法。但臧知非先生却对此批评，认为秦昭王时并无算赋，使秦代究竟有无算赋的问题引起关注。实际上，其批评不仅有违反学术规范之处，而且在史料理解上存在较多问题。更重要的是，里耶秦简证实了秦人家庭中有多妾和蓄婢现象，并证实存在着一些和父母生活的直系家庭，为算赋是向妇女专门征收的赋提供了众多可信依据。再加上传世文献和张家山汉简的佐证，便构成了一条完整的证据链，更加证明了秦代确有算赋。
Abstract:
In the past, scholars thought that the Qin dynasty had the Suanfu(Poll Tax), and the author put forward the idea that the Suanfu（Poll Tax） was only levied on women.However, Mr. Zang zhifei criticized this, thinking that there was no Suanfu（Poll Tax） in the time of the king of Zhao.In fact, his criticism not only violated academic norms, but also has many problems in understanding of the historical data. More importantly, Bamboo and wooden slips excavated in Liye confirmed that there were many concubines and maidservants in the families of the Qin dynasty, and that there were some direct families living with their parents. All of these provide a lot of credible basis for the Suanfu(Poll Tax) specifically levied on women.Combined with the historical documents and the evidence of Bamboo and wooden slips excavated in Zhangjiashan , it constitutes a complete chain of evidence, which further proves that there were really Suanfu(Poll Tax) in the Qin dynasty.

相似文献/References:

[1]刘 鹏.秦代地方禀食的几个问题[J].中国农史,2018,37(01):57.
　LIU Peng.Several Issues on the Distribution of Grain by Local Government of the Qin Dynasty[J].SAMSON,2018,37(05):57.
[2]谢 坤.岳麓秦简涉仓诸律所见秦仓制考述[J].中国农史,2016,35(06):65.
　XIE Kun.Analysis on the Storehouse System of Qin Dynasty Based on YueLu Academy’s Qin Bamboo Slips[J].SAMSON,2016,35(05):65.
[3]朱德贵.秦汉简牍所见“算赋”“口赋”再探讨[J].中国农史,2019,38(02):46.
　ZHU De-gui.Discussion on "Suanfu" and “Kou Qian “from Bamboo Slips of Qin and Han Dynasties[J].SAMSON,2019,38(05):46.
[4]谢 坤.出土简牍所见秦代仓、廥的设置与管理[J].中国农史,2019,38(03):46.
　XIE Kun.The Establishment and Management of the Warehouses and Kuai Reflected in the Unearthed Qin Bamboo Slips[J].SAMSON,2019,38(05):46.
[5]谢 坤.简牍所见秦代地方稟食原则再探[J].中国农史,2020,39(05):65.
　XIE Kun.Further Exploration on the Basic Principles of Grain Distribution by Local Governments in the Qin Dynasty Seen from Qin Bamboo Slips[J].SAMSON,2020,39(05):65.
[6]谢 坤.简牍所见秦地方稟食的粮食来源与出稟程序[J].中国农史,2022,41(03):66.
　XIE Kun.The Source of Grain and the Procedure of Local Grain Distribution in the Qin Dynasty Seen on the Bamboo Slips[J].SAMSON,2022,41(05):66.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
[收稿日期] 2018-07-31
[基金项目] 国家社科基金重点项目“秦汉简牍史料中的土地制度研究”（13AZS004）；江苏省一级学科重点学科南京师范大学中国史项目
[作者简介] 晋文（1958- ），男，南京师范大学历史系教授、博士生导师，研究方向为秦汉史。
更新日期/Last Update: 2018-11-14